Discernment: A Tool Vs. A Shield

At what point does discernment stop being a tool, and starts becoming a shield?

When trauma reshapes your mindset;  the line between the two becomes incredibly thin.  Damn near impossible to tell.

They (institutions) would have you believe, that discernment is the ability to choose reality wisely, and using it as a shield is to escape all vulnerability with having to make a choice at all. But – wouldn’t that in and of itself self be discernment?

If you measure life through a series of rigid case studies and tangible data. Then that conclusion is reasonable enough. But as many of us know through lived in experience, data doesn’t always line up with experience.

The human mind is complex, individuality is just that – unique to the individual experiencing life.

If the data shows that opening up will lead to catastrophic loss, then the most rational and logical choice you can make to survive is to build a wall.

And in that context,  the shield isn’t a failure of discernment,  it becomes the pinnacle of it.

And, if someone is already psychologically wounded then preserving what is left of their capacity becomes part of the calculation. In that state, the question isn’t simply “is this person/situation trustworthy?” It is “can I survive being wrong” 

Circling back to the published studies, you see the disconnect between the two. Because studies show humans will act out of survival. Sometimes referred to as the reptile part of your brain.

And a lot of times, the inability to trust isn’t about another person; it’s about the ability to trust your own judgement and the cost on if you chose wrong.

Leave a Reply